Comparison

Reonomy alternatives for CRE loan data: why the loans go missing, stale or wrong (2026)

Brokers, lenders and investors who compared Circlemark with Reonomy, Crexi Intelligence and Capitalize.io kept describing the same four failures: loans that aren't there, loans paid off years ago still listed, maturity dates that were never in the record, and contacts for the wrong person. Each one has a mechanical cause inside the county record. Here is what it is, how to test any vendor for it, and how we handle it — including what we found wrong in our own list, and when.

By , founder of Circlemark · · Updated · 29 min read · Figures as of Nov 20, 2026

Key numbers. In onboarding calls this month, the people who signed up for Circlemark after using Reonomy, Crexi Intelligence or Capitalize.io described the same four problems, in almost the same words: loans that should be there and aren't, loans that were paid off years ago and are still listed, maturity dates that turn out to be guesses, and a phone number or email for the wrong person. Public reviews say the same thing. A Capterra reviewer in June 2026 called Reonomy's contacts "very poor. Numerous bounced emails and phone numbers that were no longer in service"; a Better Business Bureau complaint from November 2025 says the complainant's own test of Crexi Intelligence found an inaccuracy rate "of over 50% in key contact fields"; Altus Group, Reonomy's owner, wrote in October 2025 that data quality was "one of the most frequent topics of feedback" and that it had removed more than 3 million undeliverable email addresses.

Skip the search. Type an address and the lookup reads the recorded instrument for you — lender, amount and maturity — free, no account. Or search every loan in your market on a free seat: no card, 10 owner reveals, 60 searches, nothing expires.

None of the three vendors — nor CoStar, the one most brokers on those calls already paid for — publishes whether a maturity date was read from the document or estimated, how quickly a repaid loan leaves the list, or what it last found wrong in its own data. Circlemark separates the two on every row: a maturity read from the recorded instrument is shown in bold with a citation to the page, and a modelled one is shown as an estimate with the term it assumes — ≈ 5-yr — never as a bare date. Every loan shows where each field came from and when it was last checked, and every correction that moved a count is dated on the methodology page. This post explains where each of the four failures comes from, how to test any vendor for them, and what we do differently — with the numbers. The examples and counts come from the markets we cover, New York City and Texas; the four failures, and the tests for them, apply to any county.

Reonomy alternatives for loan maturity data, named

The products people compare Reonomy against for maturing-loan work, and what each one's own published material says about where its maturity dates come from (dates read noted; the full table is below):

  • CRED iQ — CMBS, SASB, CRE CLO and agency servicer data, with county records added at varying depth; maturity-date filter and a "Maturity Wave" API; Solo $625/mo billed annually (CRE Daily review, Sep 25, 2026). The strongest choice when the loan you want is securitized.
  • Crexi Intelligence — public records and CMBS; no stated-vs-estimated flag; $249/user/mo or $2,388/yr (Capterra).
  • CoStar — a loans tab inside the leasing and comps suite, CMBS servicer data integrated in 2021; source for bank loans not stated; price not published.
  • CRE Engage — 50-state owner lookup with credit-metered contacts and "recorded loan maturity coverage" research pages; maturity method and pricing not visible on the site (read Oct 2026); trial without a card.
  • Capitalize.io — a lender database with loan records from mortgage filings, CMBS and agency disclosure attached; Solo $399/mo reported.
  • Circlemark — county-recorded loans in New York City, Dallas–Fort Worth, Houston, Austin and San Antonio, each instrument read; a maturity read from the document is shown in bold with a page citation and an estimate is marked ≈ with the assumed term; public-record owner contacts cited to their source; $149 per seat per month for the data with 100 contact reveals, $299 with 300 reveals and outreach from your own inbox; a list builder open without an account and a free seat with 10 contact reveals. Two states only.

If your market is New York or Texas, the question is whether a vendor tells you which dates it read and which it assumed; outside them, it is whether it has the loan at all. How to find maturing commercial loans covers the three sources every one of these products is built from and how to search each by hand.

The four complaints, and where each one comes from

Every commercial-mortgage dataset in the United States is built on the same raw material: roughly 3,000 county recorders, plus securitization disclosure for the CMBS and agency slice, plus a model for everything the record leaves out (where the data comes from). Reonomy says its mortgage data comes from "public county records and a handful of public and commercial databases"; Crexi says "nationwide public records"; Capitalize.io names "mortgage records, CMBS data, and Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and Ginnie Mae filings". So does ours. The differences are not in the source. They are in four decisions the vendors don't document, and each of the four complaints maps to one of them.

1. Missing loans

What users told us: "I know a building has a loan on it and your competitor doesn't show one." Or it shows the wrong one.

Why it happens. The recorder indexes documents, not loans, and the two disagree in ways a product has to resolve:

  • The loan is a consolidation. New York's larger loans are almost never a single mortgage. They are a chain of notes folded into a consolidation agreement (M&CON or a CEMA AGMT) that states the combined amount. A product that lists each note and misses the agreement shows three small loans where there is one large one; one that keeps the first document per parcel shows the wrong amount. We size loans at the document-set level: the consolidation wins, split notes sum, and the notes it swallowed are shown as consolidated, not active (how to read a portfolio loan in ACRIS). A securitized loan is the same trap from the other side: the trust discloses it piece by piece, at an address spelled the way people write it, and a product that keys on the disclosure lists the pieces beside the instrument the county recorded — 416 West 23rd Street as two CMBS notes of $25M and $35M next to its recorded $75M consolidation. We match the disclosure to the recorded instrument and list it on its own only where the county has none.
  • The amount is not in the index. Texas county clerks index a deed of trust with parties, date and legal description and no amount. A national product that builds from the index cannot filter Texas by loan size at all unless it reads page one of the instrument. Ours does, and until it has, the amount is null rather than a placeholder.
  • The loan didn't resolve to a parcel. Recorders key on legal descriptions; brokers search by address. When the lot-and-block lookup fails, the loan exists in the vendor's database and is invisible in yours. In Dallas–Fort Worth every county spells the same fact differently — Tarrant's index carries no description at all, Bexar keys everything on the New City Block — and a mismatch returns no rows rather than an error. A low match rate in one county is a bug, not a ceiling: a loan we cannot yet place is kept and retried on every county run, not dropped. The retry is measurable: about a third of Dallas–Fort Worth and San Antonio loans had never been matched to an appraisal-district parcel, and on September 30, 2026 matching on the street address the deed of trust itself states, and on survey abstract and acreage for unplatted tracts, placed about 14,600 of those properties with their parcel, owner of record, value and type.
  • A dollar floor. Every product has one and few advertise it. Ours is $1M per loan in the commercial segment, and we say so; if the loan you are thinking of is under the floor it isn't missing, it was excluded, and the vendor should be able to tell you that.

How to test a vendor: pick five buildings you know the financing on, including one consolidation and one blanket loan, and see whether the product shows one loan at the right amount for each.

2. Loans that were paid off years ago

What users told us: the most common complaint about the two older products, and the one that costs the most. A broker who emails an owner about "your loan maturing in March" when the building was refinanced in 2023 has proven to the one person who knows that they don't have current data.

Why it happens. The county record does not have a status column. A loan is "active" until the product finds the document that ends it, and those documents cite the loan indirectly:

  • In New York a satisfaction cites the notes, never the consolidation. ACRIS's satisfaction of a consolidated loan references the gap note recorded with the CEMA and the old notes it folded in — not the agreement, which is the row every product lists. A product that closes only the cited document leaves the agreement open forever. We found this in our own list. On September 21, 2026 we checked every active consolidation of $1M or more against the satisfactions recorded on its notes: 2,627 of them ($64.7B) had been paid off, and 971 had a new loan recorded within 45 days — the refinance was on the list next to the loan it retired. In all, 5,826 paid-off New York loans, 3.7% of the active list, were retired that day, and 20 of 20 random closures were checked in ACRIS by hand. A satisfaction of any note now retires the whole filing, every week. The consolidation itself does the same thing one level up: when a building refinances, the new agreement cites the old notes and never the old agreement, so the refinanced loan stays listed next to its refinance. On October 1, 2026 we re-read every consolidation recorded since 2004 against the Register's cross-reference index: 25,233 loans, one active New York row in six, had been absorbed into a later one — a Bronx apartment building showed four loans totalling $49.7M for a single $27.9M lien — and they are now shown as superseded by the agreement that absorbed them, 20 of 20 random closures checked against the index.
  • In Texas the opposite error is just as easy. A facility is perfected by a separate deed of trust per property, each stating the full note amount, and released one property at a time. Close the loan on the first release and you have retired a live $40M facility because one parcel was sold.
  • Foreclosures are ordinary deeds. New York records the outcome of a foreclosure as a deed whose grantor is the court-appointed referee; Tarrant and Collin counties have no trustee's-deed document type at all, so a foreclosure is a plain DEED told apart by who signed it. A product that goes by document type alone keeps the foreclosed loan active. When we began reading referee's deeds by parcel, 1,516 loans on our own list turned out to sit on collateral already sold at auction, and were marked foreclosed.

What the vendors say: Reonomy's pages do not state a refresh cadence for loan status; "refreshed weekly" is CRE Daily's description, not Reonomy's. Crexi publishes none. Capitalize.io publishes none. On the marketplace side, a Trustpilot reviewer in September 2025 wrote that Crexi "tend[s] to keep properties for sale on far beyond the actual completed transaction" — the same failure at the listing layer.

How to test a vendor: search for a loan you know was refinanced last year. If both the old loan and the new one show as active, you have found the problem.

3. Maturity dates that were never in the record

What users told us: a maturity date on screen, a call to the owner, and the owner says the loan doesn't mature until 2029.

Why it happens. ACRIS has no maturity field. Neither does any Texas clerk's index. The date exists in exactly two places: inside the scanned instrument, if the drafting attorney put it on a recorded page, or in a model. We have read the instruments, and the share that state a maturity on their face is:

Bar chart: share of recorded instruments that state a maturity date on the face of the document — New York plain mortgage 47%, Texas deed of trust 41%, New York CEMA agreement 6.4%, New York consolidation (M&CON) 3.4%, Manhattan's twenty largest office loans 0 of 20

Plain New York mortgages state a maturity 47% of the time (6,297 of 13,249 read); Texas deeds of trust 41%; the consolidation agreements that carry Manhattan's largest loans 3–6%, because the amended note is an unrecorded exhibit. Not one of the twenty largest Manhattan office loans has a maturity date written into the recorded instrument — for about $10.6B of their $15.3B, no stated date exists anywhere in the public record. Any product that shows those twenty loans with a hard maturity date is showing you its model.

Modelling is fine. It is the industry's standard practice and it is how prospecting lists get built. The failure is presenting the model as the record. Reonomy's API returns a mortgage's due_date as a bare date with no field saying whether it was read or estimated; its resource guide says "the mortgage maturity date tells you when a loan is set to mature". Crexi's marketing qualifies its interest rates as "estimations" but not its maturities. Capitalize.io's guide to loan maturities never raises the question. We measured our own model the same way: in a September 2026 audit of the top-20 Manhattan office loans, all five with a disclosed securitized maturity had our estimate early, three of them by about three years (ten-year CMBS paper modelled at five or seven). That is why the estimate is labelled as one, and why a stated or disclosed date replaces it the moment we have one. Every loan on Circlemark carries one of exactly two kinds of maturity, and the row says which. A stated maturity was read from the recorded instrument: it renders in bold and cites the page it came from. A modelled maturity is shown as ≈ 5-yr (or 7, or 10), meaning "estimated, assuming a five-year term from origination", with the tooltip "term assumed, not stated on the recorded document". We keep every plausible term for that lender type rather than collapsing them to one, so a "next 12 months" filter tells you which term put the loan in the window, and a stated date, once read, replaces the whole set.

How to test a vendor: ask for the stated-versus-estimated flag on a loan. If there isn't one, every date is an estimate and you don't know which.

4. A contact for the wrong person

What users told us: the complaint that came up with all three products, and specifically with Capitalize.io. The number rings a receptionist, a former partner, a lawyer, or someone with the same name.

Why it happens. The borrower on a commercial mortgage is an LLC. The record names the LLC; contact databases index people by firm; and the person who runs the LLC usually runs it from a firm with a different name. Every wrong contact is one of four substitutions:

  • The filer, not the owner. "Name and contact was for the filer of the LLC… which was a lawyer, or online LLC filing company" — a BiggerPockets user on Reonomy. The registered agent is the easiest person to find and the wrong one to call.
  • The office's other tenants. Trace a person at their office address and the skip-trace returns everyone at that address. In our September bench, address-keyed lookups at an office returned zero usable numbers; at a home address, three of three.
  • Same name, different person. "For years now I've been getting emails and texts about commercial real estate I don't own because I have the same name as someone else" — a Trustpilot reviewer, from the receiving end. A name-only match with no firm is how this happens, and a vendor that accepts it is choosing coverage over accuracy.
  • A number that was right in 2019. Bounced emails and disconnected numbers are the most common complaint in every review set we read. Reonomy's own help center says it is "unable to verify every phone number and email address in our system"; the October 2025 clean-up removed 3 million undeliverable emails at once.

Here is what an honest first pass looks like. Eleven New York loans a broker asked about, 33 owners and officers behind them, every public source plus a business-contact lookup and a skip trace, September 2026:

People
A mobile number, first pass 3
A work or personal email, first pass 8
A switchboard number only 8
Nothing from any source, first pass 16
Operating firm established, of those the record named none for 7 of 32
New work emails from those firms 4
Mobiles for office-registered principals via the firm route 5 of 10
Mobiles via a home address 3 of 3 with a home, 0 of the rest

Sixteen of 33 principals had nothing on the first pass. A product that shows a phone number for all 33 is not verifying against the person; it is filling the column. Since September 26 every unlock also reads the signature page of the recorded instrument, because the officer on file and the person who signs the debt are not always the same: on one Grand Concourse building HPD lists two members, and only the signature page said which one signs. The full method — and why findability runs opposite to authority — is in how to find the owner of a commercial property in NYC.

How to test a vendor: reveal the contacts on three buildings whose principals you already know. Count the ones that reach that person, not a person.

Is Reonomy accurate? The claims versus the reviews

Reonomy (an Altus Group business since November 2021) advertises 53M+ commercial properties, 42M+ mortgages, 30M+ owner and contact records and "verified owner contacts", sourced from "all 3,100 county assessors, Secretary of States, and census data, plus exclusive partnerships with Cotality and ICE". Pricing is listed from $400 a month on an annual plan, with monthly self-serve added in May 2026.

The reviews split the same way theBrokerList's 2020 review did: "Reonomy's property records themselves are very accurate… however, owner contact information is not always 100%." On Capterra (4.1 of 5, 33 reviews) the low scores are almost all contacts — "Ownership info is about 50/50" (April 2025), "the information is old and not accurate" (March 2023), "Over 30% of my mailings returned as no addressee or not deliverable" (BiggerPockets). CRE Daily's February 2026 roundup lists "Accuracy of data is questionable" and "Somewhat stale market insights" as cons, and its review says Reonomy "aims for about 80% accuracy" — a figure CRE Daily does not source and Reonomy does not publish.

Two things are to Altus's credit. In October 2025 it said in public that data quality was "one of the most frequent topics of feedback", that it had "corrected mortgage duplication issues" and removed the 3 million dead emails. On September 11, 2026 it announced a rebuilt contact knowledge graph with "more conservative matching and targeted validation", and warned that "some company identifiers may change" and that the verified-portfolio checkmark would be removed while it was rebuilt. That is a vendor fixing the right problem. It is also confirmation, from the vendor, that the problem was real for the four years before.

What has not changed: no stated-versus-estimated flag on maturities, no published refresh cadence for loan status, no dated record of what was found wrong and fixed.

Crexi Intelligence review: what $2,388 a year buys

Crexi Intelligence is the data layer on top of the Crexi marketplace: 153 million+ property records, 46 million+ "verified" sales and lease comps, and a monthly allowance of ownership-contact credits, listed on Capterra at $249 per user per month or $2,388 a year (reviewers report $263–$272 a month on twelve-month contracts). Its owner-contact data is supplied by a third party; BatchData publishes the case study. Crexi's own pitch for the loan side is to "identify refinance candidates by searching loan maturity dates, lender information, and interest rate estimations, then immediately access verified ownership contact details".

The marketplace is well liked — Trustpilot's 4.6 over 3,200 reviews is overwhelmingly listings and support. The Intelligence reviews are different. On G2 a review titled "'Intelligence' not very intelligent" says a filtered search returns forty properties of which "only 2 or 3 actually fit the filters… mobile home parks for apartment buildings, vacant land", and — the one loan-specific complaint we found anywhere — that "the software lacks the ability to differentiate between an arms-length transaction and a second mortgage or refi, so the mortgage valuations are dicey as well". A Trustpilot reviewer who bought it to "search mortgage data and find potential deals" wrote that they would be lucky "if 1 of 100 contacts answered" and called it "a $6,000 mistake". The November 2025 BBB complaint alleges an internal test found "a severe and systemic inaccuracy rate of over 50% in key contact fields (owner names, phone numbers)" after a sales representative had called the data "highly accurate". A counter-example from April 2026: one reviewer tested Crexi against Reonomy and ProspectNow and found its skip tracing reached "the right contact simpler and better than any other".

Crexi publishes no methodology for owner contacts, no refresh cadence for loan records, and no labelling of maturities as recorded or estimated. The word doing the work on its pages is "verified", and nothing says by whom or how.

Capitalize.io: a lender database with loan data attached

Capitalize.io (founded 2024, $4M seed in July 2025) is a different product from the other two. Its front page counts 100K+ lenders, 650K+ lender contacts, 2M+ sponsors profiled and "$2 billion+ of deals sourced and closed"; the loan records — 12 million+ mortgages, per a July 2026 profile — are built from mortgage records, CMBS data and agency filings and are there to match a borrower to a lender who has done that deal. Reported pricing is $399 a month for a solo seat and $149 a seat for teams, with outreach infrastructure billed separately.

It is too new to have a review-site footprint: no G2, Capterra or Trustpilot listing, no forum threads. The only accuracy evidence is the company's own August 2025 claim to be "seven times more accurate at identifying relevant contact information than conventional databases" — which CRE Daily's write-up rendered as seven times more accurate at "borrower-lender matches", the same number attached to two different things, with no comparator, sample or method named either time. The wrong-contact reports we have about it are from our own onboarding calls, not from public reviews, and its coverage claim — "complete, real-time coverage of every securitized commercial mortgage" — is the right claim for the CMBS slice and says nothing about the bank loans that are most of the market.

What about CoStar?

CoStar is the platform most of the brokers on our calls already pay for, and it is a different kind of product from the three above: leasing comps, listings, market analytics and, by its own 2021 count, 1,400 researchers calling brokers and landlords — with loan data as one tab. That tab sells the same use case as this post. CoStar's loans page: "Filter by lender, origination year, maturity date and more to spot refinancing opportunities, identify active borrowers, and evaluate market momentum." Its Public Record product, 42M records, offers "a record of prior loans secured against the property" and "the recorded owner and last buyer". Neither page names where the loan data comes from, how often loan status is refreshed, or whether a maturity date was read from the document or estimated. CoStar's glossary defines Maturity Date as "The date on which a borrower's final loan payment is due" and Origination Date as "The date when the loan is funded"; the only field in the glossary that carries the word "estimated" is rent.

The one CoStar loan dataset with a named source is the securitized slice. The February 2021 CMBS integration added "$1 trillion of outstanding debt information across 100,000 active CMBS loans", searchable by "current loan payment status, maturity date, most recent balance, most recent DSCR, most recent LTV" — servicer-reported data, the same slice Capitalize.io emphasises, and the release says nothing about the bank loans that are most of the market.

Public reviews of CoStar are about price and contracts first. Reported pricing runs $350–$1,400 a month by market tier (a January 2026 guide) to a median $40,000 a year for the full suite (an April 2026 one), on twelve-month terms that renew unless cancelled in writing 60 days ahead. Accuracy comes second and the complaints are old: G2's CoStar COMPS reviews (3.5 of 5) include "A LOT of the property information is inaccurate" (February 2022) and "The information is not accurate a significant amount of time" (an appraiser, April 2020); on the brokerage product, "I dislike the data integrity… I have to cross reference information with other sources" (May 2016); a BiggerPockets user "went with Yardi" because "CoStar didn't have the best data for debt". We found no public complaint about CoStar's maturity dates specifically and no accuracy review newer than 2022, so we make no claim about its loan data beyond what its own pages leave out: no stated-versus-estimated flag, no source, no refresh cadence. The nearest thing we have from a user is a Texas broker on one of our calls who could not tell, on a CoStar record, which field had been checked or when.

Is Reonomy shutting down?

No. Altus still sells Reonomy under its own name, added self-serve plans in May 2026 and shipped a rebuilt contact graph in September 2026. Reonomy data feeds Altus's ARGUS Intelligence product but the two are listed separately, and Reonomy was not part of the appraisal and development-advisory businesses Altus sold to Newmark in 2026. If a search sent you here for that question, the answer is that the product is alive and mid-rebuild.

Six questions to ask any vendor

  1. Is this maturity date read from the document or estimated, and which is which on screen? If there is no flag, every date is an estimate.
  2. How does a paid-off loan leave the list? Ask specifically about a consolidation whose satisfaction cites the old notes (New York) and a facility released one property at a time (Texas).
  3. Is a blanket or multi-property loan counted once? One financing recorded against five parcels is one debt, and a Texas facility states the full amount on every recording.
  4. Is the contact tied to the person or to the LLC? Ask what happens when the record names only an LLC and a registered agent.
  5. What is the refresh cadence for loan status, as opposed to listings, and where is it written down?
  6. What did you last find wrong in your own data, and when did you say so?

The vendor that answers all six may still be wrong about a loan. It will at least be wrong in a way you can see.

How Circlemark compares

We cover New York City and Texas (Dallas–Fort Worth, Houston, Austin and San Antonio) — not the country — and everything below applies only there. We currently track 195,394 commercial loans across those markets, — of them active and maturing within twelve months, and 47,000 with a maturity read from the recorded instrument.

Reonomy Crexi Intelligence Capitalize.io CoStar Circlemark
Coverage National National National; securitized loans emphasised National NYC + Texas metros only
Loan source County records + commercial databases Public records + CMBS Mortgage records, CMBS, agency filings Not stated for bank loans; CMBS servicer data (2021) County recorder, instrument read; ABS-EE / agency disclosure attached to the recorded loan for the securitized slice, matched by address, amount and date
Maturity labelled stated vs estimated No No No No Yes, on every row: a stated date in bold with a page citation; a modelled date as ≈ 5-yr, "term assumed, not stated on the recorded document"
Loan-status refresh Not published Not published Not published Not published Weekly per county; five guards (satisfied, superseded, modified, foreclosed, distressed)
Multi-property loans Not documented Not documented Not documented "Allocated loan amount" defined in the glossary; counting not documented One loan, parcel count shown; Texas facilities collapsed to one recording
Owner contacts "Verified", ranked by reliability; contact graph rebuilt Sep 2026 Third-party contact data; "verified" Lender contacts first Recorded owner and last buyer; researched contacts Public-record people with source and tier per name; every unlock reads the instrument's signature page and finds the decision-maker's work email first; a phone charged only when a number lands
Filters past maturity / lender / amount / type "Over 200": units, lot, building age, owner of record or person, Likely to Sell (2-yr sale score) Loan maturity, lender history, CMBS; property filters Lender, sponsor or address search CMBS slice: payment status, balance, DSCR, LTV Stated-dates-only switch; co-op and rent-regulation status; borrower as the instrument names it, linked across loans; borrower type (builder, developer, investor — the Texas register, the name elsewhere); your own borrower list, matched through its principals; parcel count; LTV; three scores shown as their parts
Says what it found wrong, and when No ("about 80%" is CRE Daily's figure) No No ("7× more accurate", unsourced) No Yes: every correction that moved a count is dated on the methodology page, e.g. 5,826 paid-off NYC loans retired Sep 21, 2026, 20 of 20 hand-checked; securitized loans listed twice beside their recorded instrument, fixed Sep 30, 2026
Listed price From $400/mo (annual) $249/user/mo or $2,388/yr Solo $399/mo, Teams $149/seat (reported) Not published; $350–$1,400/mo by market, median suite $40k/yr (reported) $149/mo (data), $299/mo (data + outreach)

The thing to take from the table is not the last column. It is that the "No"s in the middle rows — four vendors, CoStar included — are the four complaints. A product cannot show you which dates it made up, retire a loan whose satisfaction cites a different document, or reach a person the record only names by LLC, unless someone made those three decisions on purpose — and if they did, they would say so.

Filters: the ones only the record can answer

Every product in the table filters by maturity window, lender, loan amount and property type, and most go well past that. Reonomy's Building & Lot tab takes Total Units, Building Area, Year Built and Lot Size, its Debt tab takes lender, origination and maturity windows and a loan-amount range, and it searches "by owner name (LLC or individual)" (Reonomy resource pages, Jan 2024, updated Jun 2026); CRE Daily counts "over 200 filter options" (Nov 2025). Crexi Intelligence lists "loan maturity dates, CMBS data, lender history" (CRE Daily, Feb 2026). Actovia, the closest New York product, has no score but the richest filter set, including prepayment-penalty reset windows (Actovia, 2026). So a long filter list is not a difference. The difference is which questions a filter can answer when the vendor built it from the instrument rather than the index. Ours has three of those, and three more that answer who the borrower is rather than what the collateral is.

  • Stated maturity dates only. One setting drops every modelled maturity from the list and keeps a date only where it was read: a maturity printed on the recorded instrument or a securitization disclosure, a term the instrument states, or a rate-change date from the rider. "Multifamily, 12–24 months, stated only" is a list a broker can put a bank's name to without a caveat on every row. No vendor in the table publishes a stated-versus-estimated flag, so none can filter on it.
  • Co-ops and rent regulation, on the loan. In New York the collateral's regulatory status decides who can refinance it. The co-op filter keeps or drops the underlying mortgages of cooperative corporations (the Department of Finance's co-op building classes, or a borrower filing as an Owners, Tenants or Apartments Corp — never the word "co-op", which Co-op City also carries). The rent-regulation filter takes registered (the owner registered stabilized units and the count is read off the DOF tax bill, shown on the row), likely (registered, or pre-1974 with six or more residential units in a residential class, and not a co-op) or exclude. PropertyShark has had a stabilized-or-controlled filter for years, but as a property tool: its reports carry "mortgage summary data", not a lender, a maturity or a loan-status refresh. A list of stabilized walk-ups whose bank loans mature inside 18 months is ours to build.
  • Three scores, each shown as its parts. The Score column ranks by one of three models — the default (timing up to 40, date certainty 20, size 15, signals 10), Rescue & distress (past-term-no-payoff loans at full timing, plus distress, modified paper and leverage), and Size-neutral for small-balance desks — and hovering any row lists the parts that add up to it. Certainty is a part, so a modelled date can never score as a read one. Reonomy's Likely to Sell is a score of "likelihood… to be sold within the next 2 years" with no inputs, weights or validation disclosed (May 2020); the one vendor claiming a refinance model, Prospect by Buildout ("9x more likely to sell or refinance" within 12 months), publishes neither. Five templates set the common desks in one click — Bank refi, Rescue & pref equity, Small balance · non-bank, Bridge-to-perm takeout, Lender intake — and every choice lives in the URL, so a saved search, a Monday email and a shared link rank the same way.
  • The borrower, as the instrument names it. Reonomy searches "the owner of record as presented in the tax assessor record" or the true owner behind it; Crexi looks up ownership by address or parcel number. We search by the mortgagor named on the mortgage, which is the party that has to refinance it, and the borrower in every row links to every other loan to that name in the corpus — an LLC that borrows on nine buildings shows up as one book rather than nine addresses.
  • Who the borrower is. The filters above describe the collateral, the loan and the lender. Of the platforms whose published material we checked for this on October 9, 2026 — Capitalize, Forecasa, Reonomy and CoStar — none describes a filter on the borrower's line of business read from a state register (Forecasa describes borrower profiles without saying where they come from). Ours reads it where the record can: in Texas, the NAICS code the entity filed with the Comptroller, so "home builder" means the company told the state it builds houses; elsewhere, a word in the borrower's name, marked ≈ as an estimate. Most borrowers are single-asset LLCs that say nothing, and the filter leaves them out rather than guess — in Dallas–Fort Worth it reaches about a quarter of active loans.
  • Your own list. Upload a roster of firms and contacts — a builders' association directory, a sponsor list, last year's closings — as a CSV or Excel file, and pick it as a filter. A firm matches loans recorded to its name in any legal form; a person matches loans whose record names them as an officer, signer or owner of record, which is how a builder borrowing through a project LLC named after its street gets found. One 867-name Dallas builders' directory reached 685 active loans. How to find home builders' construction loans walks through both.

The rest of the bar is what you would expect from the record: counties, property type, lender by name (every spelling of one bank grouped, the originator only — never the nominee), lender type (bank, debt fund, CMBS, agency, credit union, life company), unit count, lot size (acres in Texas, square feet in New York), parcel count for blanket loans, LTV against assessed value, and recorder-side distress. All of it is in the portal. The public list builder opens the filters that name a segment to anyone, with the live count and forty real rows; the ones that walk the corpus a row at a time — borrower, lender by name, address — wait for a free seat.

What Circlemark does not do

  • Two states. If your market is not New York City or Texas, none of the above helps you, and we will say so rather than sell you a nearby one.
  • Most maturities are still modelled. Reading the instrument gets a stated date on about half of plain mortgages and almost no consolidations. The rest carry a labelled estimate, and our estimate has a measured early bias on securitized paper.
  • Lis pendens lives with the courts, not the recorder, and we don't have it yet.
  • Sixteen of 33 principals had no reachable contact on the first pass in our own bench. We show that as nothing rather than a number for someone else.

Every loan on Circlemark shows where each field came from and when it was last checked, on the web or inside Claude. If you have used one of the products above and can name the building where it was wrong, we would like to know whether we are right about it — that is how the four sections above were written.

Frequently asked questions

Is Reonomy accurate?
Reonomy's property records come from assessors and recorders and are generally sound; the complaints in public reviews cluster on owner contacts — bounced emails, disconnected numbers, and the LLC's filing agent listed as the owner. Altus, Reonomy's parent, wrote in October 2025 that data quality was one of the most frequent topics of customer feedback and that it had removed more than 3 million undeliverable email addresses. Neither Reonomy nor its parent publishes an accuracy rate; CRE Daily's 'about 80%' figure is reported, not sourced.
Is Reonomy shutting down?
No. Altus Group bought Reonomy in November 2021 and still sells it under the Reonomy name, with self-serve monthly plans added in May 2026 and a rebuilt contact graph announced on September 11, 2026. It feeds data into Altus's ARGUS Intelligence but was not folded into it, and it was not part of the businesses Altus sold to Newmark in 2026.
Is Crexi Intelligence worth it?
It depends on the job. At $249 per user per month (or $2,388 a year) it bundles nationwide property records, comps and owner-contact credits with the marketplace. Reviewers on G2, Trustpilot and the BBB describe poor filter precision, stale ownership contacts and mortgage records that do not distinguish a refinance from a second lien. Crexi publishes no refresh cadence for loan data and does not label maturity dates as recorded or estimated.
What is Capitalize.io and is its loan data accurate?
Capitalize.io is a lender-matching platform: its headline assets are a searchable lender database, lender contacts and sponsor profiles, with loan records drawn from mortgage records, CMBS data and agency filings. It is too new to have a public review footprint, so the only accuracy evidence is the company's own 'seven times more accurate' claim, which names no comparator or sample. Users we onboarded reported wrong contacts, not wrong loans.
Does CoStar have commercial loan maturity data?
Yes, as one tab of a leasing, comps and analytics product. CoStar's loans page lets you filter by lender, origination year and maturity date, and its Public Record product shows prior loans secured against a property; neither page names the source of the loan data, how often loan status is refreshed, or whether a maturity date was read from the document or estimated. The one CoStar loan dataset with a named source is CMBS: servicer-reported payment status, maturity, balance, DSCR and LTV on about 100,000 active securitized loans, integrated in February 2021. Public reviews of CoStar are mostly about price and contracts; we found no public complaint about its maturity dates and no accuracy review newer than 2022, so we make no claim about its loan data beyond what its own pages leave out.
Why do CRE data platforms show loans that were already paid off?
Because the county record retires a loan indirectly. In New York a satisfaction cites the notes a consolidation folded in, never the consolidation agreement the product lists, so the agreement stays 'active' unless the product follows the citation. In Texas a facility is recorded once per property and released one property at a time, so the opposite mistake — closing the whole loan on the first release — is just as easy. Both are choices the vendor makes, and none publishes which one.
Why is the maturity date wrong on so many commercial loans?
Most county recorders have no maturity field. The date is either read off the scanned instrument, which states one on about 47% of plain New York mortgages, 41% of Texas deeds of trust and almost no New York consolidation agreements, or it is modelled from the origination date and a typical term. A product that shows a single hard date for every loan is presenting the model as the record.
What should I ask a CRE data vendor before I trust its maturity dates?
Six things: whether each date is read from the document or estimated, and which is which on screen; how a paid-off or consolidated loan leaves the list and how quickly; whether a blanket or multi-property loan is counted once; whether a contact is tied to the person or only to the LLC; what the refresh cadence is for loan status, not just listings; and whether they will tell you what they last found wrong in their own data, and when.

Sources

  1. Reonomy: Property Debt Research — Debt tab filters (Jan 15, 2024)
  2. Reonomy: Commercial Property Search — Building & Lot and Ownership tabs (Jan 9, 2024, updated Jun 20, 2026)
  3. Reonomy: Property Owner Search — owner of record vs true owner
  4. Reonomy: Likely to Sell indicator (May 28, 2020)
  5. CRE Daily: Actovia review
  6. Actovia: NYC properties likely to sell before 2027 (2026)
  7. Prospect by Buildout: how predictive analysis works
  8. PropertyShark: how to find rent-regulated apartments in NYC
  9. Altus Group: Reonomy — Data quality improvements (Oct 31, 2025)
  10. Altus Group: Reonomy — A stronger foundation for company and contact intelligence (Sep 11, 2026)
  11. Altus Group: Reonomy self-serve pricing (May 27, 2026)
  12. Altus Group acquires Reonomy (Nov 11, 2021)
  13. Reonomy API reference — mortgage fields (due_date)
  14. Reonomy help center: What do I do if some of the ownership information listed is incorrect?
  15. Capterra: Reonomy reviews
  16. CRE Daily: Reonomy review (updated Nov 24, 2025)
  17. CRE Daily: Crexi review (updated Feb 2, 2026)
  18. CRE Daily: Best commercial real estate data sources for 2026 (Feb 18, 2026)
  19. Capterra: Crexi PRO pricing and reviews
  20. G2: Crexi reviews
  21. Trustpilot: Crexi reviews
  22. Better Business Bureau: Crexi complaints
  23. BatchData: Crexi case study (owner-contact data sourcing)
  24. BiggerPockets: Reonomy — need review? (2018–2022)
  25. BiggerPockets: CoStar vs Reonomy vs Crexi vs others
  26. Wall Street Oasis: Crexi Intelligence subscription — what's the catch?
  27. Capitalize.io
  28. GlobeNewswire: Capitalize launches AI agents for CRE financing (Aug 14, 2025)
  29. AI for CRE Collective: Inside Capitalize.io (Jul 2, 2026)
  30. The Real Deal: AI proptech startup Capitalize.io raises seed funding (Jul 21, 2025)
  31. CoStar: Loans (product page, read Oct 2, 2026)
  32. CoStar: Public Record (product page, read Oct 2, 2026)
  33. CoStar Glossary — Maturity Date, Origination Date (read Oct 2, 2026)
  34. CoStar Group: CMBS data integration (Feb 17, 2021)
  35. G2: CoStar COMPS reviews
  36. G2: CoStar Brokerage Applications reviews
  37. Real Estate Skills: CoStar reviews and pricing (Jan 16, 2026)
  38. PropertyScout360: CoStar subscription cost (Apr 28, 2026)
  39. The Real Deal: Supreme Court punts on CoStar appeal, clearing path for antitrust fight (Mar 25, 2026)
  40. NYC Open Data: ACRIS Real Property Master

Check one building

Type an address and see the mortgages recorded on it — lender, amount and the maturity read from the instrument. Free, no account.

Read next

  • How to find maturing commercial loans in 2026: the three sources, the tools that search them, and a list you can pull today

    Every maturing-loan list is built from the same three sources: the county recorder, securitization disclosure, and a model. This is how to search each one yourself, what each can and cannot tell you, how the tools that package them compare on price and on whether they admit which dates are guesses, and where to pull a list for New York or Texas without an account.

  • Ask ChatGPT which commercial loans mature next year: Circlemark is now an official ChatGPT app

    Circlemark is listed in ChatGPT's app directory. Install it in one click and ask, in plain English, which recorded commercial mortgages are coming due, who lends on deals like yours and who is behind the borrowing LLC — with every maturity labelled stated or estimated, and nothing spent without asking. The walkthrough, what each answer cites, and the by-hand route beside it.

  • Actovia and PropertyShark alternatives for commercial loan maturities (NYC, 2026)

    PropertyShark and Actovia both show a maturity date on a New York mortgage. PropertyShark's own plan page calls its dates estimated; Actovia publishes no method; Crezly, the newest entrant, says plainly that it models them. For a refinancing broker the question is narrower than "which database": which of these dates was read off the recorded instrument, and has a satisfaction been recorded since? Here is what each product's own pages say, a comparison table filled only from them, and one Manhattan loan walked from the instrument to the owner.

Comparisons

The other comparison — Circlemark beside a named vendor, on what each one reads from the record and what it models.